During a global video call for employees last month, Blackstone’s real estate chief Nadeem Meghji sought to reassure staffers about the fund’s performance. He pointed to a resumption of evictions as a reason to have “confidence in [the] cash flow growth” of its housing portfolio, according to details passed to the Financial Times after the event.
Mr Meghji told the employees that Blackstone was “seeing a meaningful increase in economic occupancy as we move past what were voluntary eviction restrictions that had been in place for the last couple of years”.
Federal law prevented landlords from evicting tenants for failing to pay rent in the early months of the pandemic, although that moratorium – like the longer-lasting versions imposed by some local governments – has been off the books for more than a year.
There is no national registry of evictions in the US, but data collated from local court records in nine states by researchers at the Eviction Lab at Princeton University suggest that many landlords returned to normal rent collection months ago.
Eviction cases quickly picked up in the summer of 2020 after coming to a near-halt in the early weeks of the pandemic. The weekly number of eviction cases recorded by the Princeton researchers steadily increased during 2021 before stabilising last summer at a rate slightly below the pre-pandemic norm.
In contrast, Blackstone’s voluntary program of assistance for needy tenants started earlier and extended far longer than those required by law. It was also more extensive than the help offered by most residential landlords.
The company waived credit card fees and penalties for late payment, allowed residents to break leases or add new roommates and did not evict anyone for failing to pay rent for more than two years.
Despite those costly support measures, Blackstone’s real estate business has outperformed publicly traded peers – helped, executives say, by a bet on rising interest rates and a focus on fast-growing population centres in the country’s west and south.
Breit reported returns of 8.4 per cent last year, even as a broad basket of public real estate investment trusts tracked by index provider MSCI lost about one-quarter of its value.
Unlike public Reits, which trade on the stock market at fluctuating prices, Breit offers investors the opportunity to sell a limited number of shares each month at a price reflecting the value at which investments are carried on the fund’s books.
But the large number of redemption requests submitted in December prompted Blackstone to impose the restrictions on withdrawals.
The eviction filings reviewed by the FT cover a handful of counties in the Atlanta area and built-up areas of Florida that represent only a fraction of the territory where Blackstone owns property.
“Given Blackstone’s massive role in the housing market, the firm’s recent move to evict tenants threatens housing stability for families in the US and around the world,” said Jim Baker, executive director of the Private Equity Stakeholder Project, an advocacy group that tracks institutional landlords.
In a statement to the FT, Blackstone said: “We believe we have the most favourable resident policies among any large landlord in the US.”
The firm added: “Eviction is always a last resort, and in each instance we offered residents a range of options, including flexible payment plans and rent forgiveness.”
In the California city of Escondido, where Blackstone bought several apartments as part of a $US1 billion deal with a local non-profit, council member Consuelo Martinez says consultants working for the firm reached out to warn her that the days of blanket reprieves for her constituents were over.
Ms Martinez says she told the consultants that she was “very concerned” by their message.
“They explained . . . how they’d been working with the residents, not collecting back rents during the pandemic even when [they] could’ve,” said Ms Martinez.
She recalls the consultants telling her: “But we’re going to start asking people to pay. [If they] can’t pay [and are] never going to be able to catch up, OK, well, then we’re going to have you leave the property.”